AvaTrade vs Skilling — which broker is better?

Pros

• Nine regulated entities, from Ireland and Cyprus to Japan, South Africa and Kenya, with the EU book run from Ireland under Central Bank of Ireland reference C53877 and Investor Compensation Company cover of 90% of losses up to EUR 20,000.
• Fixed spreads from 0.9 pips on EUR/USD mean the cost per trade does not blow out during news — a real advantage over variable-spread rivals when liquidity thins.
• AvaOptions gives retail clients vanilla FX calls and puts with a payoff-diagram strategy builder; almost no other broker of this size exposes real optionality to non-professional clients.
• Three copy-trading routes — in-house AvaSocial plus DupliTrade and ZuluTrade — rather than a single walled garden of signal providers.
• USD 100 minimum deposit, no deposit or withdrawal charges from AvaTrade, and account opening in roughly ten minutes with verification typically inside a business day.
• AvaTradeGO includes AvaProtect, a paid feature that reimburses a losing position inside a chosen window — a legitimately useful training wheel for position sizing.
• 24/5 support in more than a dozen languages across phone, email and live chat, with consistently fast chat pickup in independent contact testing.

Cons

• Dormancy is punitive: USD 50 charged quarterly after just three consecutive months without a trade, plus a USD 100 annual administration fee after twelve months. Most competitors wait six to twenty-four months.
• No real shares or ETFs. Equity exposure is CFD-only at roughly 0.13% of notional, which means no ownership, no voting and financing costs on anything held overnight.
• AvaTrade quotes as a market maker and is the counterparty to your trade — a structural conflict that agency, raw-spread models do not carry.
• No UK FCA authorisation, so UK clients are onboarded by an EU or offshore entity and fall outside FSCS protection.
• Fixed spreads are expensive in calm conditions: 0.9 pips on EUR/USD is modestly above the roughly 0.8 pips all-in cost of a good raw-spread-plus-commission account.
• The demo account expires after 21 days, which is too short to forward-test a swing strategy properly.

Pros

• Three platforms on one account: the beginner-friendly Skilling Trader, full cTrader with depth of market and cTrader Automate, and MetaTrader 4
• EUR 100 minimum on the Standard account with commission-free pricing across forex, indices, equities, ETFs, commodities and crypto
• Premium pairs EUR/USD spreads from 0.1 pips with commission of USD 35 per USD 1 million traded, which prices at or below the commission-free tier once volume builds
• CySEC licence 357/18 brings ESMA retail leverage caps and Investor Compensation Fund cover of 90% up to EUR 20,000 for EEA clients
• 800+ instruments on cTrader and Skilling Trader, including a crypto list broader than most FX-first brokers carry
• Account registration takes under a minute and the demo account has no time limit, so testing costs nothing
• Negative balance protection applies, and MAM/PAMM structures are supported for portfolio managers
• cTrader Copy provides copy trading without a separate app or a managed-fund wrapper

Cons

• Premium commission is quoted per USD 1 million of traded volume without saying whether it applies per side or per round turn, so a standard-lot round turn costs anywhere from USD 4.50 to USD 8.00 all-in — and the tier is gated by a reported EUR 5,000 minimum
• 0.70% currency conversion is expensive: converting EUR 10,000 costs about EUR 70, where the cheapest brokers charge a fraction of that, and a 2.9% charge applies to Skrill and Neteller funding
• Support runs Monday to Friday 04:00–22:00 only, with no weekend cover, while crypto CFDs trade through the weekend
• Essentially no in-house research — no analyst desk, no screener worth using, no structured market coverage; you supply your own analysis
• MetaTrader 4 is a restricted build with roughly 200 instruments and no third-party add-on support, and MetaTrader 5 is not offered at all
• CFD-only with no real ownership, and no Abgeltungsteuer or KESt withholding for German and Austrian clients